The Maury Island Incident: A Deep Dive into an Early UFO Mystery

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Maury Island Incident, a purported UFO sighting and subsequent investigation that occurred in June 1947, holds a unique and controversial place in UFO lore. It predates the widely publicized Roswell incident by mere days and is notable for its bizarre details, alleged government involvement, and the tragic deaths of two investigating officers. It’s a case study in the early days of the modern UFO phenomenon, showcasing the atmosphere of Cold War paranoia, emerging government interest in unidentified aerial phenomena, and the difficulties in separating fact from fiction in a nascent field.

The Alleged Sighting and Initial Report (June 21, 1947)

The story begins with Harold A. Dahl, who claimed to be a harbor patrolman (though his actual role is debated – some sources suggest he was salvaging logs). On June 21, 1947, Dahl, along with his son Charles, his dog, and a two-man crew, were allegedly on a boat near Maury Island, in Puget Sound, Washington.

According to Dahl’s account, they witnessed six doughnut-shaped objects in the sky. One of the objects appeared to be in distress, wobbling and descending. This central object then reportedly ejected a large quantity of metallic, slag-like material. Dahl claimed this material was hot and lightweight, some of it striking his boat, injuring his son’s arm and killing his dog. He also claimed to have taken photographs of the objects, although the quality of these photos (if they ever existed in a usable form) is highly disputed.

The “Man in Black” and Fred Crisman’s Involvement

The day after the alleged sighting, Dahl claimed to have been visited by a man dressed in a black suit, driving a black 1947 Buick. This individual, in a detail that would become a staple of UFO lore (the “Men in Black”), reportedly warned Dahl not to speak about the incident. The man supposedly knew details of the event that Dahl had not yet shared publicly, suggesting he had inside information.

This is where Fred Crisman enters the picture. Dahl’s superior (or, according to some accounts, his partner in the salvage operation), Crisman became heavily involved. He reportedly went to Maury Island to collect samples of the alleged debris. Crisman, a figure shrouded in controversy throughout his life (he would later be linked, albeit tenuously, to the JFK assassination investigation), became a key player in promoting the story.

The Investigation Begins: Kenneth Arnold and the Air Force

Dahl and Crisman contacted Ray Palmer, the editor of Amazing Stories magazine, a publication known for its science fiction content. Palmer, in turn, contacted Kenneth Arnold. Arnold, a pilot, had reported his own famous UFO sighting just days later, on June 24, 1947, near Mount Rainier. His description of “flying saucers” (a term he is credited with coining) captivated the nation and is widely considered the beginning of the modern UFO era.

Arnold, intrigued by Dahl’s story, traveled to Tacoma, Washington, to investigate. He interviewed Dahl and Crisman, examined the alleged debris, and found their story unconvincing. He suspected a hoax, but he also felt there might be something to it, even if it wasn’t extraterrestrial. Arnold, seeking further expertise, contacted Lieutenant Frank Brown and Captain William Davidson of the U.S. Army Air Forces (the precursor to the U.S. Air Force) at Hamilton Field, California.

The Ill-Fated Flight and the Death of Brown and Davidson

Brown and Davidson arrived in Tacoma, interviewed Dahl and Crisman, and collected samples of the alleged debris. They, too, were reportedly skeptical. On August 1, 1947, Brown and Davidson left Tacoma on a B-25 bomber, heading back to Hamilton Field. Tragically, the plane crashed near Kelso, Washington, killing both officers and a crew member. Another crew member was able to parachute to safety.

The crash immediately fueled speculation and conspiracy theories. Some claimed the plane had been sabotaged to silence Brown and Davidson, or to destroy the “evidence” they were carrying. The official explanation was engine failure, but the timing of the crash, so soon after their involvement in the Maury Island investigation, remains a point of contention.

The FBI Investigation and the Hoax Confession

The FBI became involved, investigating both the alleged UFO sighting and the plane crash. Their investigation, as detailed in later declassified documents, revealed a much less sensational story. Dahl and Crisman eventually admitted, separately, that the incident was a hoax.

Dahl claimed he had fabricated the story to gain publicity. He later retracted this confession, adding to the confusion. The “slag” was analyzed and determined to be industrial waste, likely from a local smelter. The photographs, if they ever clearly showed anything, were never convincingly presented.

The FBI concluded that the Maury Island Incident was a hoax, likely perpetrated by Dahl and Crisman, possibly to attract attention or even to sell the story to a magazine. However, the FBI reports also noted inconsistencies and unanswered questions, leaving room for lingering doubts.

The Legacy and Enduring Questions

Despite the official conclusion of a hoax, the Maury Island Incident remains a significant event in UFO history for several reasons:

• Early “Men in Black” Report: It contains one of the earliest recorded accounts of the “Men in Black” phenomenon, a recurring motif in UFO lore.
• Timing: It occurred just before the Roswell incident and Kenneth Arnold’s sighting, placing it at the very beginning of the modern UFO craze.
• Government Involvement: It demonstrates early government interest in UFO reports, even if, in this case, the investigation led to a dismissal.
• The Deaths of Brown and Davidson: The tragic plane crash, regardless of its cause, added a layer of mystery and tragedy to the story.
• Fred Crisman’s Role: Crisman’s involvement, and his later association with other controversial events, has fueled speculation about deeper connections and possible cover-ups.
• Ambiguity and Retractions: The fact that Dahl retracted his confession, and the overall inconsistencies in the accounts, prevent a completely clean closure to the case.

Summary

The Maury Island Incident is a complex and ultimately ambiguous case. While the official investigation concluded it was a hoax, the event’s strange details, the tragic deaths of the investigating officers, and the persistent rumors of government cover-ups have kept it alive in the annals of UFO mythology. It serves as a cautionary tale about the challenges of investigating extraordinary claims, the power of suggestion and publicity, and the enduring allure of the unknown. It also highlights the early interplay between public fascination with UFOs, government interest, and the media’s role in shaping the narrative. While likely a fabricated story, the Maury Island Incident remains a fascinating footnote in the history of the UFO phenomenon.

Last update on 2025-12-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API