Better Thinking, Planning, and Leadership for Entrepreneurs
Six Thinking Hats separates a decision discussion into six types of attention rather than asking participants to evaluate every aspect of a proposal at once. Edward de Bono’s method uses colors to distinguish information, emotion, caution, benefits, creativity, and management of the discussion. Participants can change the type of thinking they are doing without changing the subject under examination.
The distinction matters in a business meeting because statements that sound contradictory may be performing different jobs. A sales estimate describes an expected result, a concern describes a possible difficulty, and an immediate reaction expresses how someone feels. Treating all three as competing answers can make it difficult to establish what the group actually knows or what decision it is making.
The De Bono Group describes the method as parallel thinking. The participants direct their attention toward the same type of consideration during a particular part of the discussion, then move together to another. The colors identify temporary thinking roles, rather than permanent categories of people.
Six Roles for Attention
The white hat concerns information. A participant might report a measured delivery time, an observed customer behavior, or the terms of a supplier quotation. A forecast can also be discussed, with its assumptions identified. The distinction between a record and an estimate remains part of the information, rather than disappearing because both contain numbers.
The red hat concerns feelings and intuitive reactions. Someone can express discomfort with a proposed customer experience or attraction to a design without presenting that reaction as a measured fact. The statement records a response. It does not automatically establish what other people will feel or how customers will behave.
The black hat examines difficulties through reasoning. A concern becomes more useful when it identifies a specific connection between a proposal and an unwanted consequence. If a service promises same-day delivery but its supplier operates only on alternate days, the concern relates to the operating arrangement. It is different from a general dislike of change.
The yellow hat examines benefits and value. It considers who could benefit, what would improve, and the conditions under which that improvement would occur. A proposed appointment system, for example, might reduce repeated telephone calls if customers can select suitable times themselves. The benefit remains conditional on the system performing that function.
The green hat concerns alternatives and new possibilities. Participants can suggest changing the service, modifying the process, or combining elements of earlier suggestions. This part of the discussion is organized around generating possibilities rather than selecting a winner after every contribution.
The blue hat manages the thinking process. It establishes the subject, directs attention, records the output, and brings the discussion toward a defined result. A facilitator can use it to distinguish a proposal still being developed from a decision already made.
A Shared Direction Rather Than Fixed Personalities
The supplied Mind Tools text presents the hats as ways to examine a decision through different viewpoints. The practical distinction is between changing attention and assigning identities. A participant who raises a difficulty under the black hat can also identify a benefit under the yellow hat. Neither contribution requires that person to become an advocate for one side.
Permanent assignments would change the nature of the exercise. If one colleague always represents caution and another always represents optimism, the group can reproduce its usual arguments with new labels. Moving together gives each participant an opportunity to examine aspects they might otherwise leave to someone else.
The method also distinguishes knowledge from position. A person with operational experience may notice a capacity constraint, yet that observation does not make the person an opponent of the entire proposal. During a later stage, the same person may suggest a different operating arrangement that preserves the proposed benefit.
The University of Toronto toolkit includes Six Thinking Hats among its facilitation resources. Its use as a meeting structure concerns how contributions are elicited and organized. The immediate output is a more clearly separated account of the discussion, not a mathematical ranking of the alternatives.
This separation can be reflected in the meeting record. Facts can remain attached to their sources, estimates to their assumptions, and reactions to the people expressing them. Proposed alternatives can remain distinct from approved actions. A later reader can then understand how the discussion developed without treating every statement as an agreed conclusion.
Following One Proposal Through the Hats
A hypothetical small repair business provides a practical example. Its staff are considering an online appointment system. The business currently receives booking requests by telephone and email. The example concerns the structure of the discussion; it does not describe an observed company or claim a measured improvement.
Under the blue hat, the meeting’s subject is defined as whether to introduce online booking for a specified type of repair. That wording is narrower than deciding whether the business needs more technology. It gives participants a common proposal and a common boundary.
Under the white hat, the group examines its booking records, available appointment capacity, and the functions described in a supplier’s proposal. A count of booking calls belongs here if it comes from records. A guess about the number of customers who would use the new service is identified as an estimate.
The distinction changes how the material can be used. Existing call volume can describe the present workload. It does not by itself establish how many calls online booking would remove, because some callers may need advice before choosing a service. Keeping those statements separate preserves the meaning of the records.
Under the red hat, staff describe their immediate reactions. One person may welcome the convenience, and another may dislike the impersonality of an online process. Those reactions enter the discussion as reactions. The exercise gives them a place without requiring the group to invent numerical support for them.
Under the black hat, the group examines specific difficulties. An online booking could be unsuitable if the customer cannot distinguish between a short repair and a job requiring diagnosis. The concern is about the match between the information collected and the time reserved, rather than a general objection to software.
Under the yellow hat, the group examines potential value. Customers might be able to request an appointment outside opening hours, and staff might spend less time exchanging messages about available dates. Each benefit describes a particular change in the transaction. Neither requires a claim that every customer would prefer the new process.
Under the green hat, the group develops alternatives. It might consider online requests that require staff confirmation, a restricted set of bookable services, or a mixed process that retains telephone booking. These are different ways to address the same booking problem. At this stage, their function is to expand the set of options available for examination.
The blue hat then returns attention to the result of the meeting. The group can record which option it selected, which features belong to that option, and who is responsible for the next agreed step. If the meeting’s purpose was only to develop alternatives, its result can be a defined set of alternatives rather than an implementation decision.
How Contributions Change Meaning
A single sentence can contain several types of thinking. A participant might say that a supplier has quoted a price, that the price feels excessive, and that a cheaper configuration could work. Those statements concern information, reaction, and an alternative. Separating them makes each easier to examine.
The supplier quotation can be checked against its actual scope. The reaction can be acknowledged without being treated as a price comparison. The alternative can be described sufficiently to determine what it includes. The method creates different places for those operations, even when one person initially expresses them together.
The separation also helps explain why timing affects a contribution. A new idea can be useful during the green-hat stage but interrupt the group’s effort to establish factual information under the white hat. A facilitator can record it for the appropriate stage rather than interpreting the interruption as a reason to reject the idea.
Likewise, a difficulty raised during a creative stage can be retained for later examination. This does not require ignoring the difficulty. It preserves time for generating alternatives before the group applies a common evaluation to them. The record carries the concern forward without allowing it to terminate every suggestion immediately.
The relevant distinction is procedural. A participant can disagree with a proposal and still contribute accurately to a discussion of its possible benefits. A participant can favor a proposal and still identify a condition under which it would fail. The hats specify what aspect is being considered at that moment.
Information, Judgment, and Decision Authority
Six Thinking Hats organizes attention, but the organization making the decision still supplies its objectives and authority. A facilitator may guide the meeting without having the power to approve expenditure. A manager may make the final decision after considering the discussion. These responsibilities can coexist without being confused.
The method does not require equal time for every color in every meeting. A discussion about an already developed proposal may need extensive attention to operating conditions. An early design discussion may spend more time generating alternatives. The sequence can reflect the purpose of the meeting, with the blue-hat role keeping that purpose explicit.
The colors also do not create a voting system. Five favorable observations and three concerns cannot be interpreted as a five-to-three verdict. One concern could describe a condition that prevents an option from functioning, and several benefits could be different descriptions of the same advantage.
A useful record preserves those relationships. If two benefits both arise from reduced booking messages, treating them as independent gains would overstate the proposal’s value. If a concern applies only to one service category, extending it to every category would overstate its scope. Separating types of thinking makes such distinctions easier to express, but the reasoning still occurs within the discussion.
The role of emotion remains equally specific. A red-hat reaction can reveal how an employee experiences a proposal. It does not establish the emotional response of an entire customer population. When the group discusses customers, observations from customers remain different from employees’ expectations about them.
What a Balanced Discussion Contains
Balance in this method means that the proposal receives more than one kind of attention. It does not mean that every option receives equal approval, that every concern has a matching benefit, or that the final decision must fall between opposing preferences.
In the repair-business example, the discussion may favor a restricted booking service because the group has distinguished convenient appointment selection from the separate task of diagnosing repair needs. The result follows from the proposal’s operating features and the business’s objective. It is not produced merely by completing a sequence of colors.
The same distinction applies when a proposal is rejected. A discussion can identify real benefits and still conclude that the particular option does not meet the stated objective. Recording those benefits remains useful because they may be preserved in another design. Rejection of one configuration does not erase the reasoning about the customer problem.
For entrepreneurs, the method’s practical contribution is an organized conversation in which evidence, feelings, difficulties, benefits, alternatives, and decisions remain distinguishable. The participants can examine the same proposal together without making every observation an argument for or against it. A decision record then shows both the choice and the different kinds of consideration that informed it.
Useful Books Available on Amazon

